‘The Last Five Years’ Review: Nick Jonas and Adrienne Warren Star in a Muddy Revival

Jonas as a “mahvelous novelist” is a little bit of a stretch, nevertheless. Jonas as a Jew — and never only a Jew however one who impacts a Yiddish accent to sing his demented model of a shtetl people story — is much more of 1. “The Schmuel Song,” because the shtetl quantity is named, is at all times a little bit of an issue anyway; the one semi-dud within the sung-through rating, it barely is smart even when learn phrase by phrase with a magnifying glass.

Sung by Jonas, it’s mainly incomprehensible — to be honest, that’s a minimum of partially due to the widely murky sound. David Zinn’s set, a bizarre abstraction of platforms and flowers, doesn’t assist both. Solely the aptly harsh, psychological lighting, by Stacey Derosier, and Dede Ayite’s sociological costumes, give him shadings and layers.

But when he begins out too blandly likable, he improves as time reveals Jamie’s narcissism and self-righteousness. His mellow croon slowly turns into a sputtering belt. Nonetheless, I solely got here to dislike the character as a lot as Brown evidently intends when he exuberantly leaped onto the couple’s mattress along with his boots on. The cad! However by then it was too late. Cathy had walked off with the present.

Most of the time that’s the case with productions of “The Last Five Years,” and it’s to Brown’s nice credit score that he has formed the story to favor the lady although it’s mainly his personal. He’s the ur-Jamie.

However whereas the choice we hear from Jamie’s novel is meh, Brown’s achievement is unmistakable. The music (now considerably over-enhanced with the addition of a number of musicians on a crowded elevated platform) is rapturous and tough however not randomly so; it’s rapturous and tough as a result of love is just too. The lyrics specify and condense each emotions in typically scathing, at all times memorable phrases. Certainly, when Jamie sings to Cathy, close to the top of their marriage, “I will not lose because you can’t win,” it’s possible you’ll gasp at its cruelty. And but it’s possible you’ll really feel, as I did, that Warren’s Cathy might have sung the identical factor.

The Final 5 Years
By means of June 22 on the Hudson Theater, Manhattan; thelastfiveyearsbroadway.com. Working time: 1 hour half-hour.