‘Sirens’ Has Beachy Vibes but a Dark Heart

The beach-read vibes are sturdy with Sirens, a Netflix miniseries set on a moneyed northeastern island compound that, at first look, appears awfully acquainted. The hydrangeas bloom with manicured abandon. The dramatic stress is stoked with top-shelf liquor and minor acts of sophistication warfare. Completely everybody has secrets and techniques. The enigmatic trophy spouse on the middle, Michaela, is performed not by Nicole Kidman—as is, at this level, stylistic custom—however by Julianne Moore, effusing lavender mist and poisonous insecurity. Michaela is planning an end-of-summer gala, assisted by her sharp-elbowed assistant, Simone (performed by Milly Alcock), however issues are thrown into chaos with the arrival of an surprising visitor: Simone’s down-at-heel, grimly judgmental sister, Devon (Meghann Fahy).

The theatricality of the setup—the disruptive stranger, the approaching occasion that may inevitably go very fallacious—isn’t happenstance. Sirens was initially a play by the author Molly Smith Metzler (Maid, Orange Is the New Black), which premiered in 2011 below the title Elemeno Pea. Totally Netflixed by Metzler right into a five-episode adaptation, the ultimate product is a triumph of the popular-novel-to-series genre: humorous, caustic, absurd. The purpose of this sort of present, usually, is to marry coastal-mansion way of life porn with just a little mild thriller—a physique swept onto shore, a metaphorical skeleton rattling its means out of the walk-in closet. On Netflix’s The Excellent Couple, as an illustration (a 2024 adaptation of Elin Hilderbrand’s novel of the identical title), the query of who murdered a marriage visitor is much less gripping than Kidman’s high-diva flip as a matriarch with a perplexingly ambiguous accent who’s as stiff as a Barbie doll in pale-pink silk.

Learn: Nicole Kidman’s perpetual trick

Sirens, although, has a extra satirical bent, a whiff of White Lotus–esque eat-the-rich cynicism and a few really jarring perception into the purchased intimacies of lonely 0.001-percenters. By specializing in the scruffy, foul-mouthed Devon—who waits tables in a falafel store and has been single-handedly caring for her and Simone’s ailing father (Invoice Camp)—the present units up a collision based mostly on class, an outsider’s dissection of this unusual new world. Within the first episode, Devon, enraged by an Edible Association her sister has despatched in lieu of truly responding to her texts or serving to at residence, furiously carts stated fruit basket through bus, ferry, and a miles-long stroll as a way to throw lukewarm items of melon at Simone. “Don’t send me fruit, you stupid bitch,” Devon shrieks, including, with confusion, “Who are you? No, seriously. You’re dressed like a doily.”

Fahy has performed the sphinxlike spouse of a compulsive cheater on The White Lotus, and the sassy sidekick of a bride-to-be on The Excellent Couple. Devon is darker, and far funnier—bitter, sweaty, gulping water from a sprinkler by the aspect of the street in early scenes whereas an appalled canine walker watches. She’s determined to liberate Simone from what she sees as a basically poisonous job, however Simone, a yapping blond lapdog in Lilly Pulitzer, has by no means felt extra herself than she does below Michaela’s wing. And casting Moore is an interesting stretch—she’s an actor higher identified for embodying wounded birds than temperamental alphas, and so her Michaela feels notably susceptible from the get-go. Fittingly, Michaela’s quirk is that she’s turned her billionaire husband’s compound right into a sanctuary for rescued raptors, tending to birds of prey in order that they are often unleashed into the wild to kill issues anew. Her different pastime, so to talk, is described by her acolytes as her “radical generosity”—spending astonishing quantities of cash to assist girls from humble backgrounds ascend to the best climbs of society. Devon, you sense, may be her best problem but.

As thrilling as Fahy is to observe, in some methods, the dynamic between Michaela and Simone is the least predictable a part of Sirens: the managed, high-strung society queen being endlessly fussed over by her enthralled attendant. Within the first episode, Simone and Michaela examine the state of one another’s breath earlier than an occasion; when Simone’s fails to go muster, Michaela provides her assistant her personal chewed-up piece of gum, which Simone pops into her mouth with out hesitation. Simone additionally helps Michaela sext her husband, a billionaire named Peter Kell (performed irresistibly by Kevin Bacon), squeezing Michaela’s breasts collectively and drafting language that’s “dirty but not too dirty.” And perhaps it’s the Careless People of all of it, however I gasped out loud when a fragile Michaela climbed into mattress for the night time subsequent to Simone, gazing into her assistant’s eyes and demanding secrets and techniques like an 8-year-old at a sleepover.

Learn: The terrible secret of wealth privilege

Metzler is clearly fascinated by cash and sophistication, notably as they intersect with gender. Maid, which starred Margaret Qualley as a younger mom who flees an abusive relationship and finally ends up balancing on a knife-edge of homelessness and badly paid home work cleansing wealthy folks’s homes, took pains to speak all of the methods by which surviving poverty is its personal full-time job. Sirens fastidiously contrasts the repetitive, arduous work accomplished by Michaela’s employees with the #werk carried out by Michaela and her devotees. Simone’s job skirts the 2—she’s anticipated to fawn over her boss and to buttress her emotionally whereas additionally coping with the disagreeable elements of managing a family that Michaela would relatively outsource. However Sirens can also be notably considerate with regards to energy and the way girls usually wield it, blurring traces between obligation and intimacy—and realizing, all the time, that the phrases of unspecified relationships can change with out warning.

However, Sirens is a really enjoyable present. In a requisite buying scene, as Devon is made into a girl match to attend Michaela’s gala, she wears a sulky sneer all through that offsets the $22,000 noticed monstrosity her new companions gown her in. (“I look like Beetlejuice!”) Even whereas the sequence appears to sense that the dynamics between the three girls are the rationale we’re watching, it regularly throws up haphazard potential mysteries: cult-like antics, reclusive former spouses, all these birds. I perceive why, however they’re a lot much less diverting than the relationships the present excavates, the loyalty and love you should purchase however by no means absolutely depend on.

​While you purchase a ebook utilizing a hyperlink on this web page, we obtain a fee. Thanks for supporting The Atlantic.